Business Development
6
 min read

Which recruitment clients deserve more of your BD time?

Firefish & Resonant
Firefish & Resonant
Firefish Software and Resonant are working together to help recruitment agencies turn commercial strategy and CRM data into better BD decisions. David Connolly & Ben Browning, explore how to win the right work, grow client accounts and build repeat revenue. Firefish brings the CRM data and visibility; Resonant brings the commercial judgement about which work to pursue and prioritise.

If the hiring manager at your biggest client moved on tomorrow, who else there would know to call you?

A client can send you plenty of work while the whole relationship sits with one person. Another may bill less today but involve you in its plans, introduce you to other teams and give you a fair chance to fill each role. Deciding where to spend more BD time means understanding both the commercial opportunity and the strength of the relationship.

Our first article in this series explored which work is worth winning again. The next question is which existing accounts deserve more attention.

Start with return, relationships and realistic demand

Choose five accounts to review with their owners. Bring a short summary of each account’s placements, unsuccessful briefs, repeat work and commercial return. Compare permanent fees with delivery effort; for temporary and contract desks, include repeat bookings, extensions and gross margin.

Then ask what could happen next. Is there a hiring requirement your team can realistically support? What evidence suggests the client would involve you? Good relationships matter, but they need a credible commercial opportunity behind them to justify additional growth activity.

Make the five deliberately different: a high-billing account dependent on one contact; a smaller repeat client with access to other teams; an account where delivery effort is eroding the return; a lapsed client with a fresh hiring trigger; and a healthy account for comparison. Look hardest at the smaller repeat client. It deserves more growth time when there is evidence of demand, a route to the person who owns it and a realistic margin.

Five deliberately different accounts to review

Bring a short summary of each account’s placements, unsuccessful briefs, repeat work and commercial return.

  1. Smaller repeat client with access to other teams

    AskIs there evidence of demand, a route to the person who owns it and a realistic margin?

  2. High-billing account dependent on one contact

    AskIf the hiring manager moved on tomorrow, who else there would know to call you?

  3. Lapsed client with a fresh hiring trigger

    AskIs there a live hiring trigger and a credible route back to the person who owns the work?

  4. Account where delivery effort is eroding the return

    AskHow do permanent fees compare with delivery effort? For temporary and contract desks, what do repeat bookings, extensions and gross margin show?

  5. Healthy account for comparison

    AskWhat does this account show when you compare it with the other four?

Use REACH to examine the relationship

REACH brings five aspects of a client relationship into the review. Use each prompt to identify evidence, rather than relying on how well the recruiter feels they know the client.

REACH factorEvidence to look for
RhythmUseful contact between vacancies, with an agreed reason for the next conversation.
EngagementConversations about hiring plans, business priorities or recurring recruitment problems.
AlignmentMeaningful relationships across relevant hiring managers, teams or locations.
CommitmentWorkable briefs, timely feedback and decisions, and commercially sensible terms.
HeroA client who actively supports your business and advocates for you, shown by an actual introduction or referral. Who was introduced, and what happened next?
For each factor, mark the evidence and add a recent example:
  • Demonstrated
  • Missing
  • Unknown

For each REACH factor, mark the evidence as demonstrated, missing or unknown, and add a recent example. Advocacy needs a particularly clear test: “Who has this person actually introduced us to, and what happened next?” A client who likes working with you may be an ally. A client who has made an introduction has opened a door. Record what happened before treating the relationship as a route to growth.

Keep unknowns visible. In Resonant’s 2025 State of BD report, which drew on more than 500 recruitment businesses worldwide, 44% of recruiters surveyed said they often forget to update their CRM. Check gaps with the account owner before drawing conclusions, then record what you learn where colleagues can use it.

Turn the review into a decision about time

Consider this illustrative comparison.

One account produces strong permanent fees, but every instruction comes through one hiring manager. There is no confirmed demand elsewhere. The immediate priority is to protect the relationship: agree a conversation about who else influences hiring and where continuity would matter.

A second account produces less revenue through repeat temporary bookings. Feedback is reliable, another site has a confirmed staffing requirement and the current contact has offered an introduction to the person responsible. That gives the agency a specific opportunity to investigate. It warrants development time if the desk can supply suitable workers at a realistic margin.

The first account needs attention because revenue is exposed. The second has evidence supporting additional growth activity. Allocate time around those different needs.

For each account, choose the response that fits:

Choose the response that fits each account

Different accounts need different kinds of attention. Allocate time around those needs.

  • Protect

    Valuable work depends on a narrow relationship. Agree how to reduce that exposure.

    In the illustrative comparisonStrong permanent fees, but every instruction comes through one hiring manager.

  • Develop

    There is credible demand, a route to the right stakeholder and a service your team can deliver profitably.

    In the illustrative comparisonRepeat temporary bookings, a confirmed requirement at another site and an offered introduction.

  • Maintain

    The account works well, but there is no clear reason to increase development time yet.

  • Revisit

    Poor conversion, slow decisions or weak returns require a discussion about process, terms or support before further effort.

Then give each priority a next action: one decision, one owner and one next conversation.

Give each priority a next action

In Resonant’s published client-expansion example, one consultant secured placements worth £70,000 with a lapsed client. A lapsed account can earn a fresh look when there is a live hiring trigger and a credible route back to the person who owns the work. Check both before giving it a place in your BD plan.

Finish your review with one decision, one owner and one next conversation for each priority account. Set a review date and state what would justify further time: a confirmed requirement, an introduction or an agreed change to the hiring process.

Firefish’s guide to expanding an account after a placement explores how to pursue the opportunity once you have chosen it.

Make your next account review count. Use the Priority Account Scorecard below to review five clients, note what the evidence shows and choose one next conversation for each account.

Interactive tool

Priority Account Scorecard

Open each account, note the evidence and choose one next action. Each account gets an evidence check based on this article. Nothing you enter is sent or saved. Use client shorthand, such as “Client A”.

What the four next actions mean
Protect
Valuable work depends on a narrow relationship. Agree how to reduce that exposure.
Develop
There is credible demand, a route to the right stakeholder and a service your team can deliver profitably.
Maintain
The account works well, but there is no clear reason to increase development time yet.
Revisit
Poor conversion, slow decisions or weak returns require a discussion about process, terms or support before further effort.
1High-billing account dependent on one contactNo action yetProtectDevelopMaintainRevisitRhythm missingRhythm unknownEngagement missingEngagement unknownAlignment missingAlignment unknownCommitment missingCommitment unknownHero missingHero unknown
REACH evidence
FactorEvidenceRecent example
RRhythmUseful contact between vacancies, with an agreed reason for the next conversation.
EEngagementConversations about hiring plans, business priorities or recurring recruitment problems.
AAlignmentMeaningful relationships across relevant hiring managers, teams or locations.
CCommitmentWorkable briefs, timely feedback and decisions, and commercially sensible terms.
HHeroA client who actively supports your business and advocates for you. Who has this person actually introduced us to, and what happened next?

Your evidence check

  • Fill in this account to see feedback based on the article.
  • Choose one next action: Protect, Develop, Maintain or Revisit.
  • Develop needs evidence of demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Note all three before giving this account more growth time.
  • Hero isn’t demonstrated. Record who this person has actually introduced you to, and what happened next, before treating the relationship as a route to growth.
  • You’ve noted demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Develop fits when all three are credible.
  • Alignment is missing, so the relationship may rest on too few people. Protect fits when valuable work depends on a narrow relationship.
  • Commitment is missing. Revisit fits when poor conversion, slow decisions or weak returns need a discussion about process, terms or support before further effort.
  • Keep unknowns visible. Check them with the account owner before drawing conclusions.
  • Add a recent example for each factor you’ve marked as demonstrated.
  • Finish with one decision, one owner and one next conversation, with a review date.
  • You’ve recorded an action, a next conversation and the core evidence. State what would justify further time: a confirmed requirement, an introduction or an agreed change to the hiring process.

The numbers count what you’ve recorded. They don’t rank your accounts.

2Smaller repeat client with access to other teamsNo action yetProtectDevelopMaintainRevisitRhythm missingRhythm unknownEngagement missingEngagement unknownAlignment missingAlignment unknownCommitment missingCommitment unknownHero missingHero unknown
REACH evidence
FactorEvidenceRecent example
RRhythmUseful contact between vacancies, with an agreed reason for the next conversation.
EEngagementConversations about hiring plans, business priorities or recurring recruitment problems.
AAlignmentMeaningful relationships across relevant hiring managers, teams or locations.
CCommitmentWorkable briefs, timely feedback and decisions, and commercially sensible terms.
HHeroA client who actively supports your business and advocates for you. Who has this person actually introduced us to, and what happened next?

Your evidence check

  • Fill in this account to see feedback based on the article.
  • Choose one next action: Protect, Develop, Maintain or Revisit.
  • Develop needs evidence of demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Note all three before giving this account more growth time.
  • Hero isn’t demonstrated. Record who this person has actually introduced you to, and what happened next, before treating the relationship as a route to growth.
  • You’ve noted demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Develop fits when all three are credible.
  • Alignment is missing, so the relationship may rest on too few people. Protect fits when valuable work depends on a narrow relationship.
  • Commitment is missing. Revisit fits when poor conversion, slow decisions or weak returns need a discussion about process, terms or support before further effort.
  • Keep unknowns visible. Check them with the account owner before drawing conclusions.
  • Add a recent example for each factor you’ve marked as demonstrated.
  • Finish with one decision, one owner and one next conversation, with a review date.
  • You’ve recorded an action, a next conversation and the core evidence. State what would justify further time: a confirmed requirement, an introduction or an agreed change to the hiring process.

The numbers count what you’ve recorded. They don’t rank your accounts.

3Account where delivery effort is eroding returnNo action yetProtectDevelopMaintainRevisitRhythm missingRhythm unknownEngagement missingEngagement unknownAlignment missingAlignment unknownCommitment missingCommitment unknownHero missingHero unknown
REACH evidence
FactorEvidenceRecent example
RRhythmUseful contact between vacancies, with an agreed reason for the next conversation.
EEngagementConversations about hiring plans, business priorities or recurring recruitment problems.
AAlignmentMeaningful relationships across relevant hiring managers, teams or locations.
CCommitmentWorkable briefs, timely feedback and decisions, and commercially sensible terms.
HHeroA client who actively supports your business and advocates for you. Who has this person actually introduced us to, and what happened next?

Your evidence check

  • Fill in this account to see feedback based on the article.
  • Choose one next action: Protect, Develop, Maintain or Revisit.
  • Develop needs evidence of demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Note all three before giving this account more growth time.
  • Hero isn’t demonstrated. Record who this person has actually introduced you to, and what happened next, before treating the relationship as a route to growth.
  • You’ve noted demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Develop fits when all three are credible.
  • Alignment is missing, so the relationship may rest on too few people. Protect fits when valuable work depends on a narrow relationship.
  • Commitment is missing. Revisit fits when poor conversion, slow decisions or weak returns need a discussion about process, terms or support before further effort.
  • Keep unknowns visible. Check them with the account owner before drawing conclusions.
  • Add a recent example for each factor you’ve marked as demonstrated.
  • Finish with one decision, one owner and one next conversation, with a review date.
  • You’ve recorded an action, a next conversation and the core evidence. State what would justify further time: a confirmed requirement, an introduction or an agreed change to the hiring process.

The numbers count what you’ve recorded. They don’t rank your accounts.

4Lapsed client with a fresh hiring triggerNo action yetProtectDevelopMaintainRevisitRhythm missingRhythm unknownEngagement missingEngagement unknownAlignment missingAlignment unknownCommitment missingCommitment unknownHero missingHero unknown
REACH evidence
FactorEvidenceRecent example
RRhythmUseful contact between vacancies, with an agreed reason for the next conversation.
EEngagementConversations about hiring plans, business priorities or recurring recruitment problems.
AAlignmentMeaningful relationships across relevant hiring managers, teams or locations.
CCommitmentWorkable briefs, timely feedback and decisions, and commercially sensible terms.
HHeroA client who actively supports your business and advocates for you. Who has this person actually introduced us to, and what happened next?

Your evidence check

  • Fill in this account to see feedback based on the article.
  • Choose one next action: Protect, Develop, Maintain or Revisit.
  • Develop needs evidence of demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Note all three before giving this account more growth time.
  • Hero isn’t demonstrated. Record who this person has actually introduced you to, and what happened next, before treating the relationship as a route to growth.
  • You’ve noted demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Develop fits when all three are credible.
  • Alignment is missing, so the relationship may rest on too few people. Protect fits when valuable work depends on a narrow relationship.
  • Commitment is missing. Revisit fits when poor conversion, slow decisions or weak returns need a discussion about process, terms or support before further effort.
  • Keep unknowns visible. Check them with the account owner before drawing conclusions.
  • Add a recent example for each factor you’ve marked as demonstrated.
  • For a lapsed client, check for a live hiring trigger and a credible route back to the person who owns the work before giving it a place in your BD plan.
  • Finish with one decision, one owner and one next conversation, with a review date.
  • You’ve recorded an action, a next conversation and the core evidence. State what would justify further time: a confirmed requirement, an introduction or an agreed change to the hiring process.

The numbers count what you’ve recorded. They don’t rank your accounts.

5Healthy account for comparisonNo action yetProtectDevelopMaintainRevisitRhythm missingRhythm unknownEngagement missingEngagement unknownAlignment missingAlignment unknownCommitment missingCommitment unknownHero missingHero unknown
REACH evidence
FactorEvidenceRecent example
RRhythmUseful contact between vacancies, with an agreed reason for the next conversation.
EEngagementConversations about hiring plans, business priorities or recurring recruitment problems.
AAlignmentMeaningful relationships across relevant hiring managers, teams or locations.
CCommitmentWorkable briefs, timely feedback and decisions, and commercially sensible terms.
HHeroA client who actively supports your business and advocates for you. Who has this person actually introduced us to, and what happened next?

Your evidence check

  • Fill in this account to see feedback based on the article.
  • Choose one next action: Protect, Develop, Maintain or Revisit.
  • Develop needs evidence of demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Note all three before giving this account more growth time.
  • Hero isn’t demonstrated. Record who this person has actually introduced you to, and what happened next, before treating the relationship as a route to growth.
  • You’ve noted demand, a route to the person who owns the work and a realistic margin. Develop fits when all three are credible.
  • Alignment is missing, so the relationship may rest on too few people. Protect fits when valuable work depends on a narrow relationship.
  • Commitment is missing. Revisit fits when poor conversion, slow decisions or weak returns need a discussion about process, terms or support before further effort.
  • Keep unknowns visible. Check them with the account owner before drawing conclusions.
  • Add a recent example for each factor you’ve marked as demonstrated.
  • Finish with one decision, one owner and one next conversation, with a review date.
  • You’ve recorded an action, a next conversation and the core evidence. State what would justify further time: a confirmed requirement, an introduction or an agreed change to the hiring process.

The numbers count what you’ve recorded. They don’t rank your accounts.

Refreshing the page clears everything.